Sherine's Supreme Cookies

Autumn leaves on the trees begin to fall. Colors of yellow, gold, amber and brown wars us of the next season to come. Taking a trip to your local pumpkin patch and anticipating the spice aromas of cinnamon, nutmeg and cloves give us the warm and fuzzies. Add these cookies while sipping your hot cup of pumpkin spice coffee or chai for the ultimate experience of the season! 

Available from September - November Only

Just a little cookie tart with a dallop of fresh lime curd atop a light vanilla cookie. Simply sweet.  Period!

Available from September - November Only

The ULTRA-melt-in-your-mouth peanut butter cookie with just the right balance of salty and sweet. A soft consistency with a delicate velvety crumb. A palate pleasing treat! sold by the dozen
Check out Vegan Peanut Butter cookie also.  (With or without chocolate chips)

A rich and chewy vegan peanut butter cookie that does not compromise on flavor!  This cookie is satifistyingly delicious! Even a non-vegan, would fully enjoy. (no dairy nor eggs) sold by the dozen. (With or without vegan chocolate chips)

A very flavorful vanilla bean, brown sugar cookie that is soft and chewy on the inside, slightly crunchy on the ends, buttery, sweet (but not too sweet) sugar cookie.  I know that's a mouthful, however, it's a mouthful of deliciousness too? Great with coffee, tea or a glass of milk but  quite delectable all by itself. 

Sold by the dozen - 

A tender delicious almond shortbread cookie and cranberries dipped in semi-sweet chocolate that just happens to be vegan (no dairy or eggs) sold by the dozen

These little gems remind me of those candies I loved as a kid that were sold as a fund-raiser in tin cans with the key opener on the bottom. Making these beauties take me all the way back there except I've added a delectable cookie bottom, rolled in chocolate, a dollop of caramel, encrusted with toasted pecans - Bam! 


$16.95/per dozen

This oatmeal cookie is not your average oatmeal cookie. It's my Signature Cookie. The one that got all this started. I've held on to this and served to family and friends with rave reviews for more than 30 years. Whole oats, raisins, chocolate, North Carolina plump pecans, and ... well, I'm not giving away the whole kit and cabootle! But these are a winner even if oatmeal cookies have never been your favorite. Don't knock it until you've tried Sherine's. 


$14.00/per dozen

Variety Box


Variety Box


Feel free to mix your box of cookies in segments of 6 cookies with a minimum of 1/doz (12) cookies. 


Local RTP Area Only (Holly Springs, Apex, Cary, Morrisville, Durham, Fuquay, Willow Springs) & surrounding areas):

Weddings, luncheons, showers, family gatherings or reunions or whatever!
Think of Sherine's Supreme Cookies for homemade, fresh baked cookies to serve your guests.  They will thank you for sure! 

Call for pricing (minimum $75.00)

(919)  210-3384

What a wonderful way to express your care and attention to someone special. Give the gift of cookies! Giving them an opportunity to try Sherine's Supreme Cookies and they will thank you forever and ever! A single gift card covers 1 dozen cookies beautifully wrapped, shipping and handling anywhere in the US. A gift card can be electronically emailed to them or physically mailed. 

Should you require a card or cards to be physically mailed, then please include mailing information in the comments portion when filling in your order -  provide specific address details -  Call if you have difficulty, call (919) 210-3384


New Phone Number:  (919) 417-3646



September Baking Schedule:

Order by 9/7 - Shipping, pick-up, and delivery - 9/12 & 9/13

Order by 9/20  - Shipping, pick-up and delivery 9/26 & 9/27


October 2021 Baking Schedule:

Order by 10/11 - Shipping, pick-up, and delivery 10/17 & 10/18

Order by 10/25 - Shipping, pick-up and delivery 10/30 & 10/31


Stay Tuned for November & December Baking Schedules